The secret celeb explained that this particular member of her family was rather strict, and once grounded her in front of Madonna and Sean Penn for being late to dinner.
The package also hinted that her family member could be a singer, showing a record player in front of his photo.
“For a while I resented him for not making my life easy,” Calla Lily said of their relationship. “And there were years we were distant.”
Luckily, the two patched up their relationship, with Calla Lily adding, “I’m thankful for all he does for me. It made me be tough, strong and always on time for dinner.”
After her performance of the 1980s classic, the judges were given another clue: a diamond house key, which immediately gave Jenny an idea of who it could be.
“I see a house key and I see a diamond. And that sounds like a Beverly Hills Housewife to me,” the judge explained. “Put the clues together: gummy bear. Bear. Teddi. Cougar, dad’s nickname. Mellencamp. Cougar. This is Teddi Mellencamp from the Housewives.”
Jenny admitted she “could be wrong” but based on all the clues she saw, they pointed “in that direction.”
“I just honor your journey, girlfriend,” Jenny said, “and I feel so honored to have you here.”